Oury Clark Insolvency

Mond and another v MBNA Europe Bank Ltd [2010] EWHC 1710 (Ch)

Oury Clark Insolvency Blog - July 20th, 2010 by Elliot Green
  • Elliot Green

  • Position: Insolvency Partner OCA
  • Phone: +44 (0) 1753 551111
  • Fax: +44 (0) 1753 550544
  • Email: Elliot.Green@ouryclark.com
  • More information about
    Elliot Green at ouryclark.com

This case highlights that the IVA Protocol which applies to the vast majority of consumer orientated IVAs, is a voluntary code of best practice without legal enforceability over creditors.

The IVA Protocol has been widely taken up and endorsed by many organisations, including the British Bankers Association, whose members are usually representative of the largest block of creditors in many consumer IVAs.

In this case the Court declined to exercise its discretion to grant declaratory relief in the terms sought; that MBNA had to give a good reason as to the basis of its rejection of the debtor’s proposed IVA. The Court submitted that creditors who are inclined to be bound by the IVA Protocol might need more guidance from the Protocol itself on what was a good reason for rejecting an IVA.

Given the Protocol is a voluntary code, it would surprising if the Court were to impose such a code on creditors and remove the statutory right of a creditor to reject without reason a Protocol compliant IVA.

Important Information

Oury Clark cannot be responsible for comments made by our visitors. While we make every effort to assure that comments made on our blog are kept on topic, sometimes erroneous comments can be posted. If you see any comment which you believe to be inappropriate please contact the Oury Clark Webmaster imediately.


Comments are closed.